+55.53.32320232

El Niño 2026: Lessons from the 2024 Floods

Court rulings recognising the 2024 floods as force majeure in claims against public authorities rested on the unforeseeable scale of the disaster. With an official forecast now placing the probability of a very strong El Niño in 2026 at 95%, that argument becomes harder to sustain. The same applies to claims seeking contractual adjustment on the grounds of excessive hardship.

In November 2024, six months after the floods in Rio Grande do Sul reached their peak, two vessels ran aground in the Itapuã Channel, which connects Lagoa dos Patos to the Guaíba waterway on the approach to the Port of Porto Alegre. The cause was no longer the rainfall itself, but the sediment left behind in navigable channels. The incident illustrates a problem seldom adequately addressed in shipping and international trade contracts: extreme weather may last days or weeks, but its consequences can continue to emerge months later.

The extent of the disruption is reflected in the figures. The Port of Porto Alegre closed on 2 May 2024, its public quays completely submerged. At the Port of Rio Grande, strong currents at the harbour entrance restricted vessel manoeuvres to daylight hours and reduced the maximum permissible draught. By early 2025, cargo throughput at Porto Alegre was still 79% below the previous year’s level, and deep-sea shipping operations did not resume until January 2026. During that period, enquiries and disputes multiplied. Who was liable for the costs of vessels waiting to enter port? Could a Notice of Readiness (NOR) be validly tendered when the port was closed or inaccessible? Could sellers or charterers extend shipment deadlines or change the designated loading port? In most cases, the contracts offered no clear answers.

In 2026, however, there was advance warning. On 2 October, Brazil’s Federal Government reported that its El Niño monitoring panel, coordinated by the National Institute for Space Research (INPE), had identified a 95% probability of a very strong El Niño between October and December, bringing above-average rainfall and renewed flood risks to southern Brazil. The underlying exposure is also structural. A study conducted by Brazil’s National Waterway Transport Agency (ANTAQ), in cooperation with Germany’s development agency GIZ, classified Rio Grande among the ports facing a high risk from strong winds and storms. On 21 September 2026, a severe storm struck the Port of Rio Grande, causing extensive damage to its warehouses.

Such official warnings are likely to influence the legal assessment of force majeure. Under the Brazilian Civil Code, force majeure is defined by reference to an unavoidable event whose effects could not have been prevented or averted. Brazilian courts also generally consider foreseeability when determining whether an event qualifies.

Judgments recognising the 2024 floods as force majeure in proceedings against public authorities relied on the extraordinary and unforeseeable magnitude of the disaster. Following an official forecast indicating a 95% probability of a very strong El Niño, reliance on that argument becomes considerably more difficult. The same reasoning may weaken claims for contractual revision based on excessive hardship.

Under English law, which governs a substantial proportion of international charterparties and commodity sale contracts, the position is even more stringent. Force majeure is not a free-standing legal doctrine: its application depends on the express terms of the contract. The alternative doctrine of frustration is recognised only in exceptional circumstances.

In July 2026, in ADM Industries Centers Ltd (t/a ADM Israel) v Inerco Trade SA, the High Court of Justice considered the meaning of unforeseeability under the force majeure provisions of a GAFTA contract. The Court addressed foreseeability by reference to probability, distinguishing events sufficiently remote to be disregarded by the parties from risks that should reasonably have been taken into account. The judgment also reinforced the importance of complying with contractual notice requirements: failure to serve notice within the prescribed period may prevent a party from relying on the force majeure clause.

Two years earlier, in RTI Ltd v MUR Shipping BV, the UK Supreme Court had established that a contractual obligation to use reasonable endeavours to overcome a force majeure event does not, in the absence of clear wording, require a party to accept performance that departs from the agreed contractual terms.

The dispute concerned a proposal to make payments in euros rather than the US dollars stipulated in the contract. The Court held that reasonable endeavours to overcome an impediment to performance do not extend to accepting a different form of performance simply because it would achieve a commercially similar result.

That reasoning may also be relevant where alternative arrangements are proposed, such as diverting cargo to another port or arranging transhipment, but are not expressly contemplated by the contract. English courts place considerable weight on commercial certainty and the parties’ agreed allocation of rights and obligations. The contractual wording remains decisive.

The implications extend to laytime and demurrage. As a general rule, exceptions that suspend or interrupt laytime do not stop demurrage once it has begun to accrue, even if a force majeure event subsequently occurs, unless the contract expressly provides otherwise.

Flooding and sedimentation in the Guaíba–Lagoa dos Patos waterway system, much like droughts affecting northern Brazil, may increasingly be regarded as known characteristics of those waterways and port approaches. That assessment could also affect the interpretation and application of safe port and safe berth clauses.

Contracting parties are legally entitled to allocate these and other risks between themselves. A review of contractual provisions governing climate-related risks has therefore become essential.

An effective climate-risk clause should be triggered by an objectively verifiable event. This might be an official port closure, a reduction in the authorised draught below a specified threshold, or navigation restrictions imposed by the relevant Harbour Master’s Office as a consequence of severe weather.

The clause can then expressly acknowledge that the effects of El Niño or other climatic phenomena may be foreseeable, while making clear that foreseeability alone does not prevent its application.

It should also establish clear notification procedures and deadlines, identify the mitigation measures the parties are required to accept, and determine how the resulting costs are to be allocated. Provisions governing laytime and demurrage should be addressed expressly, alongside a defined period beyond which either party may be entitled to terminate the contract.

The clause may further provide that the relevant event is deemed to continue until the applicable official parameter returns to normal, rather than ending merely when the rain or wind subsides.

Equally important is consistency across the contractual chain. If a commodity sale contract suspends the seller’s obligation to ship, while the corresponding charterparty allows laytime or demurrage to continue running, the underlying risk has not been eliminated. It has simply been shifted from one party to another.

We followed the operational and contractual consequences of the 2024 floods at the ports of Rio Grande do Sul. The lesson of that disaster is clear: contracts need to be reviewed and adjusted before extreme weather events occur, particularly as such events become increasingly frequent.

Those most exposed to these risks, including sellers, shippers and charterers, should take the initiative.

Once the event has occurred, the options become far more limited. Parties may be left disputing the application and interpretation of broadly drafted contractual provisions through costly, protracted litigation, with outcomes potentially even less predictable than El Niño itself.

Arthur Rocha Baptista
Lawyer, LL.M. in International Maritime Law, and Legal Adviser to the Maritime Shipping Agencies Association of the State of Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil.

Comments

guest
0 Comments